The Advantage Top Hammer Drilling




Versatile and flexible, top hammer drilling is used by various industries all over the world. Mikko who worked in an international company selling drilling consumables and services for applications in mining, construction, tunnelling and well drilling, explains: "Arguably, the biggest advantage of top hammer drilling is the size, availability and low cost of drilling rigs.

"The rigs can be taken to challenging job locations, drilling contractors usually have machines available with short notice, and they tend to be cheaper than DTH or rotary drilling rigs.

"On the drilling consumable side, top hammer drill string is also cost-efficient, fast to set up and, thanks to the wide range of available bit designs, top hammer bits can always be optimised for the ground conditions."

The advantages and possibilities of top hammer drilling do, however, not just mean a broad range of possible applications, but also an equally broad range of clients and demands. Increased automation, longer bit durability and improved efficiency are among the requirements that need to be met by developers.

Ideal for mining and underground operations
Ideal for drilling narrow and short boreholes (down to 1in wide and up to 40m in length) in hard rock, top hammer drills are primarily used in mining, construction, and for quarrying of rock material.

"Top Hammer drilling should be the default choice for all holes with a width between 1-1/2 - 4in and a depth of up to around 30m. Ground conditions do not impact so much on the choice of drilling methodology, but it obviously has a great impact on the tool selection. An exception to this is speciality applications like tunnel forepoling, where weak ground conditions mean that forepoling is necessary - which in turn automatically calls for top hammer methodology," explains Mikko.

Specifically, the top Hammer method is widely preferred and used in underground mining operations because of the possibility of using water to flush out cuttings. Unlike other technologies, which flush with air, this improves the underground work environment by minimising the impact of drilling dust in the air.

On top of this, top hammer drilling allows for a larger number of smaller holes enabling more accurate and controlled blasting, something which is usually highly critical in underground operations.

Lastly, top hammer drilling is also required for bolting operations to secure tunnels, and, although the drilling machines used for bolting and production drilling can be slightly different, they share the same drilling methodology and require the same skillset from operators.

The challenges and limitations of the top hammer method
While advantageous in many situations, the top hammer method also has its limitations and drawbacks. One of the biggest challenges is the fact that as the drill string loses percussion energy towards the bit, longer rods will lead to a larger energy loss and less efficiency. "Speed will slow down towards the end of longer holes, and, at some point, down-the-hole drilling (DTH) will altogether be more advantageous," stresses Vuojolainen before adding, "Larger hole sizes and/or deeper holes means that at least DTH drilling should be considered, including the possibility of adding another drill rig type to the operation."

Additionally, the repeated shock waves from the hydraulic hammer on couplings and rods of top drifter drill strings create continuous wear on components, meaning that top hammer drills usually require more consumables in the long run. This also goes for drill bits which, with traditional bits, may need to be changed or sharpened several times during a work session. The requirement for manually operated replacements or upkeep, in turn, works against one of the strongest demands within the industry, especially in underground drilling, namely the demand for greater automation.

New solutions and old skills
One of the requests most often voiced by drill operators is for automated and remote-controlled drilling machines capable of drilling an entire work session before being removed for the blasting operation. But while control systems might theoretically enable this, new solutions are necessary for consumables to practically allow it.

Flexible and fast to set up, top hammer drills are ideal for narrow and short boreholes in hard rock
"The traditional drilling bits can't last long enough, but Robit developed special bits with diamond coated carbides that can perform in the desired way. That means one drill bit being able to drill typically about 3,000 - 3,300ft (900 - 1,000m), and it will be able to maintain the drilling performance well all the way towards the end of its life without sharpening," says Vuojolainen. "While the diamond bit unit cost is clearly higher than a usual TH bit, it does offer an extremely good total cost per metre payback."

Together with the general improvements in the durability of drilling consumables, operators' ever prevalent desire to improve efficiency and the consequent continuous increase in drilling power are also creating new demands to the drilling string, especially the threads. As a response, the market is seeing new thread designs, like for example shoulder supported male/female thread, that many operators have found an improvement to the traditional thread designs.

However, it is not one specific innovation or application which will decide the efficiency and profitability of top hammer drilling on a specific project. Rather it is, stresses Vuojolainen, the old skill of adding up all cost-determining factors and establishing the total drilling cost (TDC). "TDC is a sum of productivity cost of drilling in terms of time and cost per metre (drill string endurance)," he explains.

Energy saving is another key factor as sometimes drilling is set-up to drill with highest pressures, while not necessarily needed. In short, Vuojolainen concludes, what needs to be focussed on is what can be done to increase productivity by increasing drilling speed, avoiding downtime and managing the lifetime of wear products.

Top hammer drilling the method
The main distinction between the top hammer method and the down the hole (DTH) method is the placement of the percussive force within the appliance. In top hammer drilling, the activity is concentrated at the top of the drill string, above the hole, as a hammer transmits cyclical shock waves to the drill bit by applying a percussive force on the drill rods or tubes (With DTH drills, the hammer is placed down-the-hole at the bit). The percussive system strikes the drill rod with 2,000 - 5,000 strikes per minute and the rotation speed can be 60 - 200 rounds per minute. The cuttings are flushed up from the bottom of the hole with pressurised air or water.

Read more!